Pages Menu
Categories Menu

Posted by on Dec 19, 2012 in Atheism, Politics | 2 comments

Labelling Jews with a “mark of shame”?

We have to “out” them, their families, their children, their businesses and their friends. We have to make it as politically incorrect to be associated with them as they, with their BDS mates are making it for the majority of the Jewish Community in South Africa. We need to name them. We need to shame them. We need to make sure that their ability to make a living dries up. We need to label them and their families with the “mark of shame”. They are traitors and must be painted on as such. There is no space or place for half measures here. This is not something that can be negotiated. It is absolute casting into the wilderness which is required so that the next “humanitarian” will think four times before taking the same steps to attack the Jewish people, our values and our beliefs.

The question however is whether we have the courage as a community to do this?

You might think these words were written a number of decades ago, if it were not for the reference to the BDS (boycott, divestment and sanctions) movement. But no – these are the words Ivor Blumenthal, a Jewish man, published on his blog today, in reference to Jewish folk who are anti-Israel. For more on Blumenthal and his history of controversy, read this post by Nathan Geffen and Mary-Anne Gontsana. In a further amplification of this complete tone-deafness to history, the Cape Town Jewish Board of Deputies responded by saying:

Dr Ivan Blumenthal expresses a personal opinion in his blog titled “You cannot fight it darling – a Jew is a Zionist. By birth, not by choice.” The Cape SA Jewish Board of Deputies feels no need to comment on the opinions of an individual within the Jewish Community who is not speaking on behalf of any Jewish communal organisation.

But is responding to the query at all not already a comment of sorts, allowing for a judgement in respect of what was not said? How difficult would it have been to say even something as benign as “obviously, we don’t share his views, but…”? Blumenthal also says:

Centuries ago we would have stoned people like this to death. Death is today not an option because, it just so happens that in South Africa we have some of the most stringent Human Rights legislation, ironically developed and forced through Parliament by – Jews, most of them who are the turncoat, ant-semetic (sic), self-hating, treacherous Jews.

While this (for me) stops short of a call to violence, it’s still reprehensible – and whether or not it counts as hate speech under South African law, it’s nevertheless worth denouncing, loudly and wherever possible.

  • Gerhard Prinsloo

    Might be hate speech. If it is it might be prosecuted if it became more widely known as the ANC are very anti-Israel. Such laws are applied selectively here.

    Blumenthal is obviously a bigoted nut, no question, but I have some sympathy for his ire. There is a self-regarding preciousness about much of the anti-Israel lobby that takes no account of the harsh realities of the region or Palestinians’ distortion of events so often presented as fact by the media.

    • To equate Zionism – a political movement for the emancipation of Jews in
      Europe – with Jewishness simply shows this man to be an idiot without
      any idea as to the history of a movement that was originally, anti
      clergy and strictly secular.

      The Zionist movement was very much opposed – and still is – by any fundamentalist Jews because its history of representing a secular jewishness, opposed to a clergy that wanted the Jews to remain in a state of religious subservience which allowed the clergy full control over all aspects of social live, and a non participation in the affairs of the “Host” country.

      – the distortion runs both ways, and the death toll of usually 10
      Palestinians to one Jew killed in any action and the subsequent
      retaliatory action should make it clear who really wields power in

      The Palestinians feel -and rightly so – they go nowhere
      with any negotiations, as the present government in Israel pursues the
      policy to push Palestinians out by establishing settlements in areas
      that do not belong to Israel or whose ownership is in doubt.

      As to human rights in Israel – even towards their own disadvantaged Jewish citizens:

      guess they should also be labelled traitors.Labeling Palestinians
      vermin and the justification to kill Palestinian children to prevent
      them to grow up becoming terrorist (all statements by settlers on camera
      or by jewish Rabbis) just show how much some Jews learned from their
      own history of persecution – just no the right lessons.

      Mr.Blumenthal just follows the trend.