• Atheists Always Excluded From Moral Discussions

    When politicians and the media want to have a discussion about morality or when they want to appear to have the conversation, they always turn to the “faith community.” They never think to ask an atheist and they should!

    We live in a bizarre world in which those who defend and hide child molesters are considered more of an authority on morality than those in the greater community of reason who advocate for a science-based approach to morality.

    Apparently, Joe Biden met with twelve members of the “faith community” to discuss the morality of guns laws. But he didn’t ask any atheists our opinions on the topic. We have been having a reasoned discussion on this very topic recently too. Sam Harris and Sean Faircloth (among others) have been laying out reasoned arguments for their views. Regardless of which side of the issue you fall on, it would be to Biden’s benefit to have both these people in that meeting. It would be far more constructive than any priest, rabbi, or imam.

    When it comes to morality, who cares what some ancient book dictates? Sure, we can learn a lot from ancient books like Aristotle’s Nichamochean Ethics, but only in the light of how we can use what Aristotle said to think about our modern moral understandings. Saying something is moral because Aristotle dictated it, would be almost as moronic as saying that something is moral because the Bible dictated it.

    Atheists need to start to demand that we be included in these conversations. If these conversations take place on television or behind the closed doors of the White House, we need to be there and be represented. We should wage massive campaigns to those who don’t include a representative from the greater community of reason.

    “None” make up an estimated 19% of the population and many of those 19% hold a reason based view of morality. We need a seat at the table. We demand it!

    Enhanced by Zemanta

    Category: AtheismAtheist ActivismMoralityPoliticsSocial Justice


    Article by: Staks Rosch

    Staks Rosch is a writer for the Skeptic Ink Network & Huffington Post, and is also a freelance writer for Publishers Weekly. Currently he serves as the head of the Philadelphia Coalition of Reason and is a stay-at-home dad.

    One comment

    1. therte is what you might call a partially underground college that is invited to participate in moral discussion on many subject; but the problem is that they aren’t welcome in the traditional comercial media. This is especially true if they challenge the ideology of those that run the corporations. I would we4lcome Sam Harris’ input; but it would need scrutiny. When he attempted to justify the use of torture or a potential justification for a first strike nuclear scenario I have no doubt that it wouldn’t stand up to scrutiny and he ignored many of the facts that the comercial media have also ignored. The athiests or probable atheists at the American Empire Project did a better job covering that and they aren’t welcome at the MSM.

      Another big group that is excluded from the discussion on moral issues are those that study how violence escalates, like Alice Miller, Murray Straus and Philip Greven; or those that study how comercialization hurts education like Susan Linn or the people from the Nationalization Policy Center. The result is greater potential for violence and dramatic reduction in the quality of education due to corporate indoctrination by Charter Schools or school advertising.
      Also I’ll throw in one religious person that is mostly supressed from the mainstream; James Garbarino who knows a lot about how to reduce violence; and religious people will be more inclined to listen to him becasue he is religious. He’s excluded becasue he challenges media violence. His work is mostly what I would consider secular but he does make some case for religion that would appeal to some.

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *