• Hold your glee, fellow liberals: Progressive religion won’t be a match for conservatives

    A recent study by Public Religion Research Institute has brought cheers for the political left. According to Think Progress, “Religious Progressives will soon outnumber the conservatives”.

    “Our new research shows a complex religious landscape, with religious conservatives holding an advantage over religious progressives in terms of size and homogeneity,” Dr. Robert P. Jones, CEO of Public Religion Research Institute, said in a press release. “However, the percentage of religious conservatives shrinks in each successive generation, with religious progressives outnumbering religious conservatives in the Millennial generation.”

    Really?
    Really?

    There are reasons to be skeptical of the rather grandiose claim made by Think Progress. To begin with, according to the study, 22% of the millennial generation are non-religious, whereas past surveys have put the number quite a bit higher. This raises questions about Public Religion’s methodology. Further, the fact that there are no longitudinal data makes making predictions for the future on the relative numbers of religious liberals and conservatives difficult.

    But even that not withstanding, taking a look at other data points from the same polls raise serious questions about the claim that religious progressives will “outnumber” conservatives. As it happens, among those will a religious affiliation, close to half think their religion should keep its traditional beliefs and practices, while only less than 30% think it should change with the times.

    change

    And while for some religious people the teachings of the faith about the poor mean creating a fairer society, for more it simply means being charitable as individuals.

    lib
    Which is not so different from the libertarian “keep the government out of my pocket, I can give to the poor better myself” mantra.

    While I consider myself a liberal, I think if liberals are hoping for future wins, they need to bet on the religiously unaffiliated, because that is more likely to pay off for them.

    Category: Uncategorized

    Article by: No Such Thing As Blasphemy

    I was raised in the Islamic world. By accident of history, the plague that is entanglement of religion and government affects most Muslim majority nations a lot worse the many Christian majority (or post-Christian majority) nations. Hence, I am quite familiar with this plague. I started doubting the faith I was raised in during my teen years. After becoming familiar with the works of enlightenment philosophers, I identified myself as a deist. But it was not until a long time later, after I learned about evolutionary science, that I came to identify myself as an atheist. And only then, I came to know the religious right in the US. No need to say, that made me much more passionate about what I believe in and what I stand for. Read more...